1Several reviewers describe the SC Elite V4 as an accessible, comfortable, non-aggressive super shoe that is approachable for a wide range of runners.
If you want a carbon-plate racer that does not feel harsh or intimidating, the SC Elite V4 is repeatedly cited as one of the more friendly, accessible options on the market.
2 creators11 opinions
Opinions (11)
Doctors of Running describes the New Balance Fuel Cell SC Elite V4 as 'not the fastest of all the super shoes out there' but 'one of the more comfortable ones and one of the less aggressive ones.'
New Balance SC Elite V4 vs. V5 | Still the Super Shoe for Recreational Runners?Watch sourceDoctors of Running recommended the SC Elite V4 to people 'just getting into a super shoe' as a great option.
New Balance SC Elite V4 vs. V5 | Still the Super Shoe for Recreational Runners?Watch sourceDoctors of Running recommended the SC Elite V4 to people who are 'not the fastest runner' and 'don't want the most aggressive shoe' but still want a super shoe.
New Balance SC Elite V4 vs. V5 | Still the Super Shoe for Recreational Runners?Watch sourceDoctors of Running finds the SC Elite V4 'very comfortable' and says 'I could even walk around in this and it was fine.'
New Balance SC Elite V4 vs. V5 | Still the Super Shoe for Recreational Runners?Watch sourceThe Run Testers characterizes the SC Elite V4 as one of the more friendly carbon plate shoes, accessible to lots of runners, while the SC Elite V5 is a move toward a more aggressive racing shoe that will suit some people better and some people worse.
New Balance SC Elite v5 First Run Review: What’s new vs the New Balance SC Elite v4?8:16The Run Testers finds the key takeaway of the SC Elite V4 is that it is a very accessible marathon shoe that does not detract from the experience, delivering a very polished ride, but it is competing against a lot of strong carbon racing shoes.
Best Carbon Plate Running Shoes 2024 | Top racing shoes from Asics, Nike, Hoka, Adidas, Puma & more30:30The Run Testers (Nick) finds the SC Elite V4 is a very accessible shoe, very comfortable, and quite mellow for the amount of propulsion and punch it delivers; it feels quite chilled on the foot but still delivers a fast ride.
Best Carbon Plate Running Shoes 2024 | Top racing shoes from Asics, Nike, Hoka, Adidas, Puma & more30:30The Run Testers finds the SC Elite v4 is not his favorite race shoe among the carbon plate racers out there, but calls it a solid comfortable option that is quite accessible for a lot of people.
The Big Half 2024 Race Test | New Balance SC Elite V4 and Suunto Sonic Headphones4:11The Run Testers finds the SC Elite v4 is a good accessible option for people looking for a carbon racer who do not want something like the Endorphin Elite or the Alphafly; it is a little more natural feeling than those.
The Big Half 2024 Race Test | New Balance SC Elite V4 and Suunto Sonic Headphones4:11The Run Testers finds that for most people the SC Elite v4 is going to be a really solid comfortable option.
The Big Half 2024 Race Test | New Balance SC Elite V4 and Suunto Sonic Headphones4:11The Run Testers states the SC Elite V4 is a more approachable carbon shoe all round compared to the SC Pacer V2.
New Balance SC Pacer v2 Review: Two runners rate New Balance’s lightest racing shoe16:27
2Multiple reviewers find the SC Elite V4 lacks top-end speed, propulsion, and aggressiveness compared to the fastest super shoes.
Runners chasing maximum pop and forward propulsion for short races or elite-level pacing may find the SC Elite V4 underwhelming; it is not the shoe for those who want to be pushed forward.
3 creators9 opinions
Opinions (9)
Doctors of Running describes the New Balance Fuel Cell SC Elite V4 as 'not the fastest of all the super shoes out there' but 'one of the more comfortable ones and one of the less aggressive ones.'
New Balance SC Elite V4 vs. V5 | Still the Super Shoe for Recreational Runners?Watch sourceDoctors of Running states some people have run 'some really fast times' in the SC Elite V4, but it is 'just not the top top racing shoe on the market at that time.'
New Balance SC Elite V4 vs. V5 | Still the Super Shoe for Recreational Runners?Watch sourceThe Run Testers finds the SC Elite V4 probably is not as aggressive and propulsive as some other shoes in the video but is much closer to being a marathon-friendly New Balance shoe than previous versions.
Best Carbon Plate Running Shoes 2024 | Top racing shoes from Asics, Nike, Hoka, Adidas, Puma & more27:40The Run Testers finds the SC Elite V4 is a really cruisy shoe that protects legs really well, but it may lack the top gear and range available from other carbon shoes, possibly because New Balance also has the SC Pacer V2 in its lineup.
Best Carbon Plate Running Shoes 2024 | Top racing shoes from Asics, Nike, Hoka, Adidas, Puma & more30:30The Run Testers finds the SC Elite v4 is not as aggressive as some of the carbon plate racers.
The Big Half 2024 Race Test | New Balance SC Elite V4 and Suunto Sonic Headphones4:11The Run Testers finds the SC Elite v4 is definitely not the most propulsive shoe out there; it does not feel like it is really pushing you forward.
The Big Half 2024 Race Test | New Balance SC Elite V4 and Suunto Sonic Headphones4:11The Run Testers finds the SC Elite v4 is better for longer distance events, specifically better for a marathon than for 10k and 5k events; it does not have a lot of pop for those shorter distance races.
The Big Half 2024 Race Test | New Balance SC Elite V4 and Suunto Sonic Headphones4:11The Run Testers states he still probably would not pick the SC Elite v4 for a race because they just do not have the aggressiveness, responsiveness, and bounce that he likes from his shoes.
The Big Half 2024 Race Test | New Balance SC Elite V4 and Suunto Sonic Headphones4:11Yowana observes that the New Balance SC Elite V4 has 'absolutely no get up and go'.
20 Mile Long Run in the On Cloudboom Strike 252:21
3Reviewers consistently recommend the SC Elite V4 for longer distances, particularly the marathon, over shorter races like 5K and 10K.
The SC Elite V4's comfort and cushioning suit it to marathon and long-run duty rather than short, fast racing where pop and responsiveness matter more.
2 creators6 opinions
Opinions (6)
The Run Testers finds the SC Elite V4's midsole feels a lot nicer for longer distances.
Best Carbon Plate Running Shoes 2024 | Top racing shoes from Asics, Nike, Hoka, Adidas, Puma & more27:40The Run Testers finds the SC Elite V4 definitely leans much more towards long distances; the reviewer has done some workouts in it and prefers longer stuff and workouts at marathon race pace rather than moving anything faster than that.
Best Carbon Plate Running Shoes 2024 | Top racing shoes from Asics, Nike, Hoka, Adidas, Puma & more30:30The Run Testers finds the SC Elite v4 is better for longer distance events, specifically better for a marathon than for 10k and 5k events; it does not have a lot of pop for those shorter distance races.
The Big Half 2024 Race Test | New Balance SC Elite V4 and Suunto Sonic Headphones4:11The Run Testers observes that for longer distance races the SC Elite v4 has a nice consistent transition and feels quite comfortable to wear.
The Big Half 2024 Race Test | New Balance SC Elite V4 and Suunto Sonic Headphones4:11The Run Testers states the SC Elite V4 would be a very good option for the marathon and you could do short distances in it as well.
New Balance SC Pacer v2 Review: Two runners rate New Balance’s lightest racing shoe16:27Doctors of Running states the SC Elite V4 is 'the more relaxed ride' that he thinks 'is going to work a lot better for recreational runners.'
New Balance SC Elite V4 vs. V5 | Still the Super Shoe for Recreational Runners?2:56
4One reviewer (Kieran, The Run Testers) reported significant heel rubbing and holes from the SC Elite V4, and other reviewers from the same outlet corroborate that the V4's heel design has been known to cause blisters or Achilles aggravation for some runners, prompting a redesign in later New Balance models.
The heel design is a recurring pain point; consider sizing up a half size and be cautious if you have had Achilles or heel-fit issues in other New Balance racers.
1 creator7 opinions
Opinions (7)
The Run Testers (Kieran) states that New Balance's race shoes have a tendency to cut people's heels up, and attributes that experience to the SC Elite V4 specifically.
Best Running Shoe Brand Rotations | We pick the best three-shoe rotations from the top brands18:47The Run Testers (Kieran) observes that the SC Elite V4 gave him holes in his heels, which prevented him from being able to put it back on; he speculates that he should have sized up or half-sized up.
Best Running Shoe Brand Rotations | We pick the best three-shoe rotations from the top brands18:47The Run Testers (Kieran) says the only thing that felt good about the SC Elite V4 was everything else apart from the fact that it makes holes in you.
Best Running Shoe Brand Rotations | We pick the best three-shoe rotations from the top brands18:47The Run Testers notes the only thing not accessible about the SC Elite V4 is potentially the heel design, which has chopped up some people's heels, but the reviewer has been okay with it.
Best Carbon Plate Running Shoes 2024 | Top racing shoes from Asics, Nike, Hoka, Adidas, Puma & more30:30The Run Testers experienced an issue with the SC Elite v4: rubbing quite a lot on the top of his feet, especially on downhills during the Big Half race.
The Big Half 2024 Race Test | New Balance SC Elite V4 and Suunto Sonic Headphones4:11The Run Testers speculates he should have sized up half a size in the SC Elite v4; he wore size 8 and thinks he should have gone for 8.5 because the upper section of the front of the shoe is a little bit shallow on his toes, causing rubbing.
The Big Half 2024 Race Test | New Balance SC Elite V4 and Suunto Sonic Headphones4:11The Run Testers speculates that going half a size up in the SC Elite V4 would not have hurt for him, and that if a runner is between sizes or half sizes in the SC Elite V4, a similar story applies to the Rebel V4.
New Balance 1080v14 Vs New Balance Rebel V4 | We compare two of New Balances daily shoesWatch source
5Multiple reviewers describe the SC Elite V4 upper as wide, high-volume, and accommodating, particularly for wider or higher-volume feet.
The SC Elite V4 is one of the more accommodating carbon racers for wider feet; runners who find most super shoes too narrow may appreciate its roomier fit.
2 creators9 opinions
Opinions (9)
Doctors of Running recommended the SC Elite V4 to people needing a super shoe for a wider foot or higher volume foot, saying its upper was 'really, really great for that.'
New Balance SC Elite V4 vs. V5 | Still the Super Shoe for Recreational Runners?Watch sourceDoctors of Running describes the SC Elite V4 upper as 'higher volume' and notes he 'really had to lock the laces down' because he doesn't have a higher volume foot.
New Balance SC Elite V4 vs. V5 | Still the Super Shoe for Recreational Runners?5:40Doctors of Running describes the SC Elite V4 fit as 'wider' with an upper that was 'nice and stretchy with the Phantom fit.'
New Balance SC Elite V4 vs. V5 | Still the Super Shoe for Recreational Runners?5:40Doctors of Running states the SC Elite V4 upper 'is going to have a lot more room throughout' compared to V5.
New Balance SC Elite V4 vs. V5 | Still the Super Shoe for Recreational Runners?5:40The Run Testers observes that the SC Elite V5 has a much narrower upper and a less voluminous forefoot compared to the SC Elite V4; the upper sits lower and closer to the toes and is more narrow.
New Balance SC Elite v5 First Run Review: What’s new vs the New Balance SC Elite v4?3:00The Run Testers , who has a narrow foot, prefers the fit of the SC Elite V5, but notes that if a runner liked the width and extra room of the SC Elite V4, that is gone in the V5.
New Balance SC Elite v5 First Run Review: What’s new vs the New Balance SC Elite v4?3:00The Run Testers observes that the SC Elite V5 loses the cushy feel of the SC Elite V4; the V4 had foam on either side of the foot as well as underneath because it is such a wide shoe, but the V5 does not.
New Balance SC Elite v5 First Run Review: What’s new vs the New Balance SC Elite v4?5:45The Run Testers states that if you were a big fan of the SC Elite V4, you are not going to like the SC Elite V5 as much because it is quite a different feel; it does not have the width, stability, cushiness, and friendliness of the V4.
New Balance SC Elite v5 First Run Review: What’s new vs the New Balance SC Elite v4?5:45The Run Testers states the SC Elite V4 is a slightly more accommodating fit compared to the SC Pacer V2, making it better suited for longer distances.
New Balance SC Pacer v2 Review: Two runners rate New Balance’s lightest racing shoe13:38
6Reviewers find the SC Elite V4 midsole soft, bouncy, and cushioned, with a plush ride that rolls through nicely.
The full-PEBA FuelCell foam delivers a soft, bouncy experience that prioritizes comfort over raw speed, making it feel more like a cruiser than a rocket.
2 creators8 opinions
Opinions (8)
Doctors of Running finds the SC Elite V4 'very soft underfoot.'
New Balance SC Elite V4 vs. V5 | Still the Super Shoe for Recreational Runners?Watch sourceDoctors of Running finds the SC Elite V4 has 'soft, bouncier ride that rolls really nicely.'
New Balance SC Elite V4 vs. V5 | Still the Super Shoe for Recreational Runners?Watch sourceThe Run Testers notes the SC Elite V4 uses the PEBA version of Fuel Cell, which is the bounciest and most impressive foam in New Balance's lineup.
New Balance SC Pacer v2 Review: Two runners rate New Balance’s lightest racing shoe0:01The Run Testers finds the ride of the SC Pacer V2 is a lot less cushy and springy than the SC Elite V4.
New Balance SC Pacer v2 Review: Two runners rate New Balance’s lightest racing shoe5:34The Run Testers states the SC Elite V4 has a bouncier feel in terms of the midsole compared to the SC Pacer V2.
New Balance SC Pacer v2 Review: Two runners rate New Balance’s lightest racing shoe13:38The Run Testers states the SC Elite V4 has a bouncier feeling, a softer feeling, more of a rocker, and is a more cushy shoe than the SC Pacer V2.
New Balance SC Pacer v2 Review: Two runners rate New Balance’s lightest racing shoe16:27The Run Testers states the SC Elite V4 has changed more than any other carbon shoe over four generations, going from a stripped-back low-profile shoe to a very comfortable, cruisy shoe (RC Elite 2), to a stripped-back lighter version (V3), and now V4 which is rocked but has a load of foam and a full PEBA midsole that is bouncy, smooth, and fun.
Best Carbon Plate Running Shoes 2024 | Top racing shoes from Asics, Nike, Hoka, Adidas, Puma & more27:40The Run Testers observes that the SC Elite V5 loses the cushy feel of the SC Elite V4; the V4 had foam on either side of the foot as well as underneath because it is such a wide shoe, but the V5 does not.
New Balance SC Elite v5 First Run Review: What’s new vs the New Balance SC Elite v4?5:45
7Reviewers find the SC Elite V4 stable for a carbon-plate super shoe, citing its wide base, central groove, and mild guidance features.
Despite its soft foam and high stack, the SC Elite V4's wide platform and centered geometry make it a stable option for runners who want security in a race shoe.
3 creators8 opinions
Opinions (8)
Doctors of Running finds the SC Elite V4 is 'fine' in terms of stability and 'actually fairly guided' and 'fairly central because it's a really wide sole.'
New Balance SC Elite V4 vs. V5 | Still the Super Shoe for Recreational Runners?2:56Doctors of Running notes the SC Elite V4 has a 'really nice central groove throughout the middle that saves weight and also keeps it somewhat centered.'
New Balance SC Elite V4 vs. V5 | Still the Super Shoe for Recreational Runners?2:56Doctors of Running states the SC Elite V4 has 'some nice mild guidance for those that might need it on top of the softer sole.'
New Balance SC Elite V4 vs. V5 | Still the Super Shoe for Recreational Runners?2:56Doctors of Running states the SC Elite V4 has 'some mild sidewalls.'
New Balance SC Elite V4 vs. V5 | Still the Super Shoe for Recreational Runners?2:56Doctors of Running finds the SC Elite V4 is 'somewhat centered' in its stability bias.
New Balance SC Elite V4 vs. V5 | Still the Super Shoe for Recreational Runners?5:40Doctors of Running states the SC Elite V4 'is going to be the less biased option' in stability compared to the V5, and 'it's soft' but 'not a stability shoe' — 'it's going to be more centered.'
New Balance SC Elite V4 vs. V5 | Still the Super Shoe for Recreational Runners?5:40The Run Testers observes the SC Elite V4 has gone up a little bit in weight, but on the positive side it is very controlled and very stable.
Best Carbon Plate Running Shoes 2024 | Top racing shoes from Asics, Nike, Hoka, Adidas, Puma & more27:40Yowana ranks the SC Elite V6 at 7 or 8 out of 10 for race-shoe stability, comparing it to the SC Elite V4 (which he calls 'very stable') and other stable racers like the Adios Pro 3.
Best Race Shoe? New Balance SC Elite v6 vs Puma Deviate Nitro Elite 47:16
8One reviewer (Doctors of Running) measured the SC Elite V4 at a 4 mm heel-to-toe drop and found it noticeably low, reporting it worked his calves more than expected; a second outlet (The Run Testers) separately corroborates the 4 mm figure when comparing it to the V5's 8 mm drop.
The unusually low 4 mm drop for a marathon racer may strain calves; runners sensitive to drop or coming from higher-drop shoes should ease into it.
2 creators4 opinions
Opinions (4)
Doctors of Running states the SC Elite V4 has 40 mm heel stack and 36 mm forefoot stack for a 4 mm drop.
New Balance SC Elite V4 vs. V5 | Still the Super Shoe for Recreational Runners?Watch sourceDoctors of Running describes the 4 mm drop of the SC Elite V4 as 'very, very low' and says 'that was noticeable.'
New Balance SC Elite V4 vs. V5 | Still the Super Shoe for Recreational Runners?Watch sourceDoctors of Running states the 4 mm drop of the SC Elite V4 'kind of worked my calves a little bit too much for me.'
New Balance SC Elite V4 vs. V5 | Still the Super Shoe for Recreational Runners?Watch source- The Run Testers
[Brand] lists a stack height of 40 mm at the heel and 32 mm at the forefoot for the SC Elite V5, giving an 8 mm drop, which is double the 4 mm drop of the SC Elite V4.
New Balance SC Elite v5 First Run Review: What’s new vs the New Balance SC Elite v4?0:01
9Several reviewers characterize the SC Elite V4 as a big, "massive," or boat-like shoe that feels less compact and direct than other carbon racers.
The SC Elite V4's size and bulk are defining traits; runners who prefer a stripped-back, racy, on-foot feel will likely find it too large and cushioned.
2 creators7 opinions
Opinions (7)
- Yowana
Grant compares the New Balance SC Elite V4 (referred to as 'Elite V4') to the Topo Spectre Elite, saying the Spectre Elite 'almost like New Balance SC Elite V4' — it was a shoe that 'was super massive.'
The Best & Worst Shoe Releases of Summer 202617:52 - Yowana
When describing the Topo Spectre Elite, Grant says it 'almost like New Balance SC... Elite V4 or yeah, Elite V4. That one that was super massive.'
The Best & Worst Shoe Releases of Summer 202625:19 - Yowana
Grant observes that the SC Elite V4 'was super massive' in feel.
The Best & Worst Shoe Releases of Summer 202625:19 Yowana compares the OnCloud Boom Strike 2 to the New Balance SC Elite V4, stating that the Boom Strike 2 reminds him of the SC Elite V4: 'just a boat thing that has absolutely no get up and go' and 'they've neutered it'.
20 Mile Long Run in the On Cloudboom Strike 252:21The Run Testers compares the ASICS MetaSpeed Sky Paris to the New Balance Fuel Cell SC Elite V4, describing the latter as a 'bigger carbon shoe'.
ASICS Metaspeed Sky Paris Marathon Test: Is ASICS' new carbon race shoe any good over 26.2?4:04The Run Testers characterizes the New Balance Fuel Cell SC Elite V4 as a 'bigger carbon shoe' that is less compact and less direct than the ASICS MetaSpeed Sky Paris.
ASICS Metaspeed Sky Paris Marathon Test: Is ASICS' new carbon race shoe any good over 26.2?7:18The Run Testers finds that the ASICS Metaspeed Sky Paris feels unlike the New Balance SC Elite V4 — comparing the Sky Paris to the New Balance SC Elite V4, the reviewer says the Sky Paris feels like "a smidge of the original Vaporfly" compared to "bigger carbon shoes" like the New Balance SC Elite V4.
Best Running Shoes 2024: The top running shoes in The Run Testers' rotations right now24:34
10A minority of reviewers strongly dislike the SC Elite V4, calling it mushy, dead, sloppy, and lacking any "get up and go."
While most reviewers find the shoe comfortable, a vocal minority find the softness and width translate to a dead, unresponsive feel; this is a risk for runners who prioritize snap and ground feel.
3 creators5 opinions
Opinions (5)
Sagasu Running states he tried on the SC Elite V4 last year and had the same negative feelings about that shoe as he did about the Rebel V4.
New Balance Rebel v5 - Evolution complete24:43Sagasu Running attributes a similar set of problems to the SC Elite V4 as the problems he found with the Rebel V4 — mushy, dead, sloppy fit, wide, and a multi-piece outsole that lets the foam squish out every direction.
New Balance Rebel v5 - Evolution complete24:43Yowana compares the OnCloud Boom Strike 2 to the New Balance SC Elite V4, stating that the Boom Strike 2 reminds him of the SC Elite V4: 'just a boat thing that has absolutely no get up and go' and 'they've neutered it'.
20 Mile Long Run in the On Cloudboom Strike 252:21Yowana observes that the New Balance SC Elite V4 has 'absolutely no get up and go'.
20 Mile Long Run in the On Cloudboom Strike 252:21The Run Testers describes the SC Elite V4 as feeling really unnatural, very rockered, and overly cushioned when they first pulled it on during a comparison session.
New Balance SC Pacer v2 Review: Two runners rate New Balance’s lightest racing shoe7:57
11One reviewer (Doctors of Running) finds the SC Elite V4 versatile across paces, working for easy runs and marathon pace, while a second outlet (The Run Testers) separately notes it delivers a comfortable, 'fast ride' despite feeling mellow.
The SC Elite V4 can double as a long-run trainer and a marathon racer, making it a good do-everything carbon shoe for recreational runners who do not need a dedicated short-course racer.
1 creator2 opinions
Opinions (2)
Doctors of Running finds the SC Elite V4 is more versatile than the V5, working whether running at easy pace, slower pace, or picking up the pace.
New Balance SC Elite V4 vs. V5 | Still the Super Shoe for Recreational Runners?2:56Doctors of Running states the SC Elite V4 'has a little more accommodating fit' and 'a little more relaxed ride that works still for faster paces, but also for easier stuff.'
New Balance SC Elite V4 vs. V5 | Still the Super Shoe for Recreational Runners?5:40
12Multiple reviewers observe the SC Elite V4 is a popular shoe seen on many runners at races and recommended as the shoe most people get on with.
The SC Elite V4's broad appeal and popularity suggest it works for a wide range of runners, which may provide confidence for buyers seeking a proven, crowd-pleasing option.
2 creators3 opinions
Opinions (3)
Doctors of Running says the SC Elite V4 can be found on sale and notes 'there's a reason why this series has been really, really popular' — 'it works for a lot of different people.'
New Balance SC Elite V4 vs. V5 | Still the Super Shoe for Recreational Runners?5:40The Run Testers observes that a lot of people were wearing the SC Elite v4 at the Big Half race, calling it a clearly popular choice of shoe.
The Big Half 2024 Race Test | New Balance SC Elite V4 and Suunto Sonic Headphones4:11The Run Testers (Nick) states that for a New Balance rotation, the SC Elite V4 is the race shoe option; he opines that it is probably the shoe most people get on with.
Best Running Shoe Brand Rotations | We pick the best three-shoe rotations from the top brands15:43
13One reviewer (Doctors of Running) measured the SC Elite V4 at approximately 254g in a men's size 10, and reviewers from The Run Testers separately note that the V4 is heavier than its V5 successor and remark that its weight 'has gone up a little bit' generation over generation.
At roughly 254 g the SC Elite V4 is not a lightweight racer by modern standards; runners sensitive to weight may prefer the lighter V5 or sub-200 g competitors.
1 creator1 opinion
Opinions (1)